The assignment this week is to evaluate the textbook. There is an old saying tells us that we should not believe all in what books are trying to tell.
The information/knowledge in books is not necessarily correct. that is also why the government have to verify textbooks before they publish, in order to examine if they are really suitable for learners to use. The followings are the book evaluation based on the twelve criteria edited from Robinett:
Book 2 for 7th Grade
Chia Yin-Han Lin Version
1. Goals of the course
According to the General Guidelines of Grade 1-9 Curriculum of Elementary and Junior High School Education, which announced by Ministry of Education in Taiwan, there are three basic goals of English courses for elementary and junior high school students:
a. Build up the basic ability of students for communicating in English with people, and are able to apply the language to real situations in their daily life.
b. Help students to find more interests in learning English and learn it with some more amusing ways, in order to learn spontaneously effectively.
c. Promote students’ understanding of their country and foreign cultures, in order to compare and respect cultural differences.
Besides the goals above, there are Competence Indicators which divided into two stages, 3th Grade to 6th Grade in elementary school and 7th Grade to 9th Grade in junior high school. The textbook is for junior high school, so it focuses on the four skills of listening, speaking, reading and writing. It emphasizes the actual application and gives students opportunities to use what they have learned of English in the first stage, in order to develop the new knowledge of the language.
2. Background of the student
The aim students for this textbook are 7th graders in junior high school, within the age 12 to 14. Most students’ mother tongue is Mandarin, but some of them are still from other groups, such as Southern Min, Mainlanders, Hakka, aborigines. Since English is a universal language, even students are from different backgrounds, they all have to learn English. When talking about the education, some kind of issues like curriculum reform and curriculum Integration have being discussed for a long time. The government in Taiwan has been doing lots efforts and editing the policies of education again and again, however, there is no doubt that diplomaism still exists. It seems that students lose their original motivation of learning after they left the so-called “happy life” in elementary school. As people know, cram schools might be something less than convenience stores on the streets in Taiwan. With this kind of learning background, it is much more important for teachers to think how to choose the textbook and materials for students to use.
3. Approach
The Teacher’s manual indicates that teachers should create the language learning environment where students can receive meaningful exposure to the target language. To involve students in it, teachers have to design the courses by using some activities involving real communication and also give opportunities for students to do some meaningful tasks. In this textbook, it provides teacher and students with various activities which courage them to have more interaction----teacher to students, students to students, making students learn in communicative activities. There are some pre-reading questions and a picture in the beginning of every lesson, which make students understand about the context of language use and overview what they are going to learn in this lesson. The topics and materials in the textbook are quite close to students’ daily life experience, like celebrating some special days, learning months and dates, or how to make a cake. These different topics and materials not only raise students’ interest in learning English but also help them understand the foreign culture. Teachers could use the four skills to teach all the topics, and the teaching would be more efficient with some other visual aids or media aids. In this way, learners could have more impressions on what they learn.
4. Language skill
The four skills of listening, speaking, reading and writing are validly included in this textbook.
a. Listening
The listening parts in the textbook focuses on “Dialogue”, “Exercise”, “Fun with Sounds”, “Song” and “Challenge”. As to the content of them, all of them are quite simple , practical and authentic, for example, “Dialogue” in lesson one is about how to make a phone call or answer the phone. In “Practice”, teachers play CDs and students have to circle the right answers.
b. Speaking
There is one part, “Dialogue” which especially emphasizes the pronunciation improvement, and there are also sections such as “Listen and Repeat” and “Tongue Twister” which focuses on the skill of speaking.
c. Reading
The “Reading” and “Comic” could train students’ reading skill.
d. Writing
The “Sentence Pattern” and “Answer the Questions” give students chances to practicing writing skill.
5. General content
As mentioned above, the chosen topics are quite close to students’ life experience, such as names of foods, sports, and animals. What’s more, the vocabulary and grammar of each unit are completed in the meaningful context, such as in the family talk or a conversation in the classroom. However, the subject matter cover the topics correspond to the life experience of teenagers, but it might neglect the needs and backgrounds of those students who live in the rural area, and other racial minority groups.
6. Quality of practice material
The “Practice”, “Exercises” and “Review” parts give students chances to practice what they learned in class.
7. Sequencing
The textbook is sequenced by the following parts, “Warm-up”, “Dialogue”, “Theme Words”, “Sentence Pattern I”, “Sentence Pattern II”, “Practice”, “Activity”, “Reading” and “Exercise”.
8. Vocabulary
The vocabulary is introduced in the natural and realistic sentences, dialogues, or essays toward accomplishing the ultimate goal of language communication. Also, the textbook put much attention on the purpose of communication, and the text is treated as a whole. Therefore, students do not have to memorize the vocabulary one by one, what they have to do is to know when and how to use the vocabulary in what situation.
9. General socio-linguistic factors
It is not very obvious to see this point in the text book, but there is indeed one topic of introducing Father’s Day in Taiwan and USA, which is related to the society and helps students to get familiar with the cultural background and understand the foreign culture as well.
10. Format
The format of the textbook could be evaluated from the following parts:
a. The type size is convenient enough, and is also appropriate for the learners
b. There are functional typefaces, a detailed table of contents which includes location of structures and their respective exercises with an index of new vocabulary items and their location, appendices and so on.
c. There are some simple graphic devices such as boxes, shading, color, arrows effectively used to clarify the presentation of grammatical structures.
d. The illustrations are clear, simple, and free of unnecessary details that may confuse the learners.
11. Accompanying materials
The accompany materials of the text book is Students’ Workbooks. There are about six pages of each unit for students to review and practice what they learn in class. What students have to do is answering the questions and giving the right answer, so sometimes it might be kind of boring for students to do.
12. Teacher’s guide
The “Teacher’s guide” helps teachers understand the objectives and methodology of the text, and give suggested answers for the exercises in the textbook. It also shows teachers how to teach students with an overall class design. The “Teacher’s guide” gives teachers techniques for activating students’ background knowledge before reading the text, suggest a clear, concise method for teaching each lesson and provides additional exercises for reinforcing grammar points in the text.